More like 'I Love What You Did With Your Hair This Summer,' right?

She has a strange perspective on canon.

This is too funny.

It's a good time to be a horror fan.

Speak what you want into existence!

Aging like fine wine!

Honestly, I couldn't tell you, Jen.

Fix it!

The fairest of them all.

The host was definiely prepared for the evening.

Julie James is back!

Who's behind the hook this time?!

Could Tom Cruise's (alleged) final mission be solving a huge franchise mystery?

You could even say that people are quite hooked on this latest tease.

I still have a problem with a few things.

Gellar is back—well, sort of—to keep the Fisherman’s hook sharp!

Take a bow, Rachel!

The next Fisherman had better start sharpening their hook.

I Know What You Did Last Summer is bringing its slasher vibes back to modern audiences, but one core cast member has always had to drop out.

Brandy survived I Still Know What You Did Last Summer, and she deserves to return for the new sequel.